​Subscribe | Advertise​
​Join 63,553 smart people
​Brought to you by Insense​

Find your perfect influencers in 48hrs — who actually follow the brief! ​ Stop DMing creators and hoping for the best. ​Insense is your all-in-one solution for UGC + influencer marketing. They’ve got 68K+ vetted creators from 35+ countries worldwide and will match you with the right one in under 48 hours - even for niche markets. But the best part? From UGC to seeding to whitelisted ad for Meta and TikTok, Insense handles it all. Why We Buy readers can get $200 for their first campaign - but only until July 31, 2025. ​ ​​→ Book a free demo today and save $200​

​
Imagine this…
​
You’ve had a day.
​
The kind where everything that could go wrong did—from losing your keys to accidentally saying “Love you” to a major client when you ended a call. Needless to say, you’re stressed

And it’s the kind of stress that only ice cream can solve.
​
There’s just one problem…
​
Sugar always makes you feel like you’ve been run over by a Mack truck. Plus, you’ve been trying to eat healthier overall and don’t want to derail your progress.
​
Thankfully, you’ve got a secret weapon stored in your freezer for emergencies days like this.
​
You pull it open and voilà—there it is: a pint of Halo Top in Mint Chip.
​
Normally, a serving of regular ice cream is just half a cup and packs 250+ calories and loads of sugar.
​
Plus, you end up feeling yucky thanks to the sugar crash.
​
But when you see the Halo Top tub, you don’t have to weigh the pros and cons like you normally do when craving sweets.
​
Instead, you whip out a spoon and dig in with zero hesitation.
​
​Why did eating a pint of Halo Top feel smart?
​
​In today’s special edition of Why We Buy 🧠, we’ll explore a well-known company to see how they use buyer psychology principles in their business.
​
This week we’re diving into Halo Top—the ice cream brand that made indulgence something to feel good about.
​
​Let’s get into it.

​
​🤑 A Look Inside Halo Top

When Justin Woolverton started making ice cream in his kitchen, it wasn’t to build a billion-dollar brand.

It was to avoid a sugar crash.
​
He needed to keep his blood sugar levels in check, but he also had a sweet tooth—and an ice cream maker.
​
After a year of trial and error with ingredients, he finally found the perfect blend that tasted sinful, without the sugar overload.
​
This story turned into Halo Top, the brand that disrupted the industry with a better-for-you ice cream that actually tastes like ice cream.
​
So people no longer had to choose between eating “healthy” and eating dessert.

By 2017, Halo Top was the best-selling pint of ice cream in the U.S., beating out giants like Ben & Jerry’s. And Time magazine called it one of the year’s best inventions.
​
So it’s no surprise that just two years later, Wells Enterprises scooped up (hehe) Halo Top in a deal insiders estimated was around $2,000,000,000.
​
Pretty sweet, huh?
​

🧠 How Halo Top Uses Buyer Psychology

Halo Top is known for being a lighter ice cream that doesn’t taste light. But they don’t rely on taste alone. Here are some other sweet (and smart) ways they’ve won over customers’ freezers:
​​
​Framing​
​
With the “Stop Shoulding Yourself” campaign, Halo Top reframed eating dessert as something you should enjoy—not something you should feel guilty about.

It tackled nagging, unhealthy thoughts like “I ‘should’ feel bad about dessert” with a firm message: Stop “shoulding” yourself and start enjoying the delicious things life has to offer (like a pint of Halo Top).
​
So instead of feeling restricted, customers felt like they finally had permission.
​
​Psst... Wanna uncover the ouchiest problems *your* buyers are struggling with? Check this out >

​
Pattern Interrupt​
​
Most ice cream brands save their nutrition facts for the *back* of the carton. Not Halo Top.
​
They plaster the total calorie count on the front of the package, topped with a gold, halo-like lid (get it?).

That bold number breaks shoppers' autopilot stroll through the freezer aisle and gets them to take a closer look. (Before tossing a pint—or three—into their cart.)
​

Regret Aversion​
​
If you were to eat a full pint of regular ice cream, you’d likely end up feeling queasy and think to yourself, “What have I done?”

Halo Top neutralized that fear by showing their ice cream isn’t *just* lower in calories. It’s better for you, being low in sugar while high in protein.
​
So you don’t end up regretting it afterward. Instead, you feel satisfied.

​

🤔 Thinking About Your Business

You don’t have to create an ice cream brand to get a taste of sweet success.

Ask yourself…
​
​Q: Are you framing your offer as a restriction or a reward?

If your marketing tells people what they shouldn’t do, you risk triggering resistance. But when you reframe your offer as something desirable that they get—something they deserve—you shift the energy completely. Your message and offer become a green light. So what can you give your buyers permission to believe?
​
​
​Q: Are you interrupting buyers’ autopilot mode?

Most buyers scroll through feeds and inboxes on cruise control. So if your marketing looks and sounds like everything else (or worse, “AI slop”), it’ll get ignored. What unexpected visual or story can you use to snap your buyer out of their routine and get them to pay attention to you?
​
​
​Q: What’s your buyer’s biggest possible regret—and how can you remove it?

​Regret is one of the ultimate roadblocks to making sales. If a buyer worries they’ll feel foolish, guilty, or disappointed after saying “yes,” they’ll hesitate (or ghost you). Your job is to make the decision to buy from you feel safe. That means addressing their hidden doubts head-on and showing them why those doubts won’t come true with you.

​
💥 The Short of It

By making buyers feel smart for treating themselves, Halo Top turned a frozen treat into a billion-dollar brand.
​
Because at the end of the day, Halo Top didn't sell ice cream. They sold a license to indulge.
​
And customers bought in by the pint.
​​
​​Until next time, happy selling!

With ❤️ from Katelyn and Jordyn​

​