Hot Hand Fallacy 🧠 Why We Buy


Subscribe | Advertise​
​
Join 63,553 smart people

Brought to you by Tapistro​

🤔 Did you know...

In their attempt to do what no NFL team had ever accomplished—win three Super Bowls in a row—the Kansas City Chiefs didn’t just lose Super Bowl LIX.
​
They got blown out by the Philadelphia Eagles.
​
Keep reading to find out why talking heads and fans were so certain the Chiefs would win their third Super Bowl—despite the odds *not* being in their favor. 🏈

Read time: 2.9 minutes ⚡

Your GTM workflow needs more than just one buying signal
​
​
A funding round, a hiring spree, a new ad campaign. Each could mean an account is ready to buy... or nothing at all. Tapistro routes accounts to your reps only when three things line up: ICP fit, a buying trigger, and research to confirm they're a hot lead today.

Not sure which buying signals matter for your ICP? Get a free report to uncover 3 signals that drive purchase intent.

​
​→ Get your free Signal Triangulation Report​

Exclusive for the Why We Buy readers. No credit card required.

Imagine this…
​
It's Wednesday evening and you're sprawled on your couch, still in work clothes, mindlessly scrolling through your phone.
​
You uncover that fitness app you downloaded four months ago but never actually opened—until three days ago.
​
“Hmmm. I am kinda on a streak,” you think as you open the app and browse through beginner workouts.
​
Next thing you know, you’re pushing the couch back in the living room to make space before you trade your slacks for yoga pants and tap “Start workout.”
​
The first few moves are basic—squats, arm circles, modified push-ups. Nothing too intense, and you're actually keeping up.
​
​Thirty minutes later…
​
​
You're sweating, but somehow you've made it through every single exercise without dying.
​
Then you hear digital confetti explode.
​
“Day 3 Complete!” The screen reads, flashing your shiny new badge and "3-day streak" in big, bold letters.

Suddenly you feel completely transformed—like a fitness guru who could squat an elephant.
​
You immediately start searching for tomorrow's 30-minute workout and seriously consider upgrading to premium for the nutrition plan.
​
You even text your friend about your "new fitness journey."
​
​Why does completing three workouts make you feel like fitness success is now inevitable?
​
​
In today’s edition of Why We Buy 🧠 we’ll explore Hot Hand Fallacy—why we believe a streak of past successes makes future success more likely.
​
​
Let’s get into it.

🧠 The Psychology of Hot Hand Fallacy

We tend to believe the odds of a player making the next shot is greater following a hit than a miss. After all, they’re on a hot streak.
​
But researchers analyzed detailed NBA shooting records…
​
And found little evidence that making one basket made a player more likely to make the next one, despite our strongly held beliefs.

But there’s some recent research that suggests “hot hands” is not a cognitive illusion—at least in baseball where defensive adjustments can’t easily hide short-term streaks.
​
So what does this all mean for your customers?
​
People naturally spot hot streaks and assume they’ll continue, whether the streak is real or random.
​
And that’s why smart marketers help customers perceive their purchase as a win.

​
🤑 How To Apply This

Alright, so how can you apply this right now to sell more?
​

Finance​
​
Use a track record to make company wins feel transferable to customers
​
​
Vanguard doesn’t bore you with a dense company history lesson on their About page.
​
They showcase salient stats, including a 10-year winning streak of their mutual fund and ETFs outperforming their peer-group averages.

That unbroken run of wins makes a nervous investor think, “They’ve been on a hot streak for a decade, why would they stop now?”
​
And suddenly, parking your retirement savings there feels less like a gamble and more like a smart decision.

​
Email marketing
​
​
Use streak counters to make wins feel unstoppable
​
​
Every week, Grammarly sends users a progress report showing their active writing streak and productivity stats.
​
When you see you’ve been writing for 143 weeks straight and you were 88% more productive than other users, it feels like you’re on a roll.

And once your brain decides you’re on a winning run, using Grammarly next week feels like a no-brainer to keep your hot streak alive.
​

SaaS​
​
Show a streak of big customer wins to build buying confidence
​
​
Slack doesn’t just rely on copy to do the heavy lifting on their homepage. They immediately name-drop major companies using the software before you even start scrolling.

One impressive customer could be a fluke.
​
But a wall of recognizable logos like OpenAI and Stripe? Phew. That shows more and more smart companies keep choosing Slack. So potential users see the pattern and think, “This is clearly a winning tool.”
​
And that’s the kind of momentum thinking that pulls you toward the “Get started” button.

​
💥 The Short of It

Our brains are wired to see winning streaks and assume they'll continue, even if the odds are completely random.
​
The important part is helping your customer feel like they’re winning with your product or service so they’re more likely to keep using it and loving it.
​​
​
​
​Until next time, happy selling!

With ❤️ from Katelyn​

P.S. Wanna *really* get inside your buyer’s head?

There are a few ways we can help:

​

Why We Buy 🧠

Discover the hidden reasons why people buy. Join 73,000+ fans and become a smarter marketer 🧠

Read more from Why We Buy 🧠

Issue #009 • 1 min 51s FYI: You just read an issue of my new newsletter, UNIGNORABLE. Don't worry.You'll still get Why We Buy too. (If you don’t want to receive this, unsubscribe here) I find it absolutely fascinating that companies never challenge how we're going to be effective at driving revenue until things are going wrong. Chris Walker If you aren’t challenging the status quo, you’re missing a powerful opportunity: naming the problem your audience cares deeply about and positioning...

Issue #008 • 2 mins 02s FYI: You just read an issue of my new newsletter, UNIGNORABLE. Don't worry.You'll still get Why We Buy too. (If you don’t want to receive this, unsubscribe here) Living the life we want requires not only doing the right things; it also requires we stop doing the wrong things that take us off track. Nir Eyal, Indistractable: How to Control Your Attention and Choose Your Life If you think you need to stake your personal brand on a single idea forever, you're leaving the...

Subscribe | AdvertiseJoin 63,553 smart people Brought to you by AnotherZero 🤔 Did you know... You’ve probably lost a client to a competitor you know you're better than. Not because your offer was worse.Not because your price was wrong.But because they just looked better. Keep reading, today we're going to fix that… 👀 Read time: 3.9 minutes ⚡ Imagine this... You're on a sales call. You're good at what you do. You know it. Your past clients know it. But the person on the other end of that call?...