​Subscribe | Advertise​
​Join 63,553 smart people
​Brought to you by Blaze​

Many AI tools produce slop. This one doesn't. ​ ​No more choosing between slow, expensive agencies or AI tools that spit out mediocre content. ​ ​Blaze is the world’s first AI marketing platform that actually produces high-quality, human-feeling content. ​ The best part? You get strategy, content, and insights all in one platform—at up to 99% cost savings. ​ See why 15,200+ brands use Blaze. ​ ​​​→ Start your free 7-day trial​ ​No credit card required

Imagine this…
​
You're scrolling through Instagram when you see a golden retriever devouring what looks like actual food from a bowl.
​
The caption reads: "Day three of eating The Farmer's Dog, and Bella's living her best life with waaay more energy!"
​
You glance over at your corgi, Penelope—sprawled on the couch like a sloth, refusing to touch the kibble you poured for breakfast.
​
​"Maybe it's time to try something different," you think.
​
You head to The Farmer’s Dog website and fill out a questionnaire asking about your dog's breed, age, and activity level. Within two minutes, you've got a personalized meal plan for the month.
​
The price makes you hesitate for a second.
​
But then you remember last month's $350 vet bill for *ahem* digestive issues.

Your dog is like your kid (if you had a kid). You’d do anything for her. So you click "Place order."
​
Three days later, a big box sits on your front porch. You open it to find pre-portioned meals, with Penelope’s name on each one.
​
You tear a pack open and pour half of it into her bowl.
​
She inhales it in 30 seconds flat, then looks up at you like you've just given her the best meal of her life.
​
​Why does this dog food feel like a necessity rather than a splurge?
​
​In today’s special edition of Why We Buy 🧠, we’ll explore a well-known company to see how they use buyer psychology principles in their business.
​
This week we’re diving into The Farmer’s Dog—the dog food brand that delivers millions of fresh meals each month.​
​
Let’s get into it.
​
​
​🤑 A Look Inside The Farmer's Dog

It all started with a rottweiler named Jada who had gnarly digestive issues.
​
After trying nearly every pet food on the market with no luck, her owner, Brett Podolsky, followed the vet’s suggestion to make her homemade food.
​
The results were dramatic: Jada’s health improved almost immediately.
​
But he stumbled onto a bigger realization…
​
Dogs are eating the same traditional “dog food” that has been around for ages. And yet serious health issues like dental disease and obesity are running rampant.
​
With the belief that health starts with what’s in dogs’ bowls, he and his friend Jonathan Regev launched The Farmer’s Dog: a subscription service delivering human-grade, fresh dog food right to your door.

The pitch was simple: Long live dogs.
​
And pet owners ate it up (pun intended).
​
No starchy fillers. No mystery meat. Just real, human-tested, vet-approved ingredients you can actually see and pronounce.
​
Within 10 years, The Farmer's Dog grew to over $1 billion in annual revenue, proving that treating pets like family isn’t just good ethics—it’s great business.
​

🧠 How The Farmer’s Dog Uses Buyer Psychology

The Farmer's Dog turned "any food will do" into "I need this for my dog right now." How? By understanding what really drives pet parents to sign up for a subscription.
​
Here are a few tail-waggingly smart techniques:

​
Storytelling

In 2023, The Farmer's Dog aired a Super Bowl ad that had millions of viewers sobbing into their pizza rolls.
​
The ad showed a little girl growing up alongside her dog—from childhood playtime to college send-offs to welcoming her first child.
​
The tagline? "Nothing matters more than more years together.”

Everyone wishes their dog could live forever. And by pulling at our heartstrings and showing—not telling—that feeding fresh food is a way to substantially extend the amount of time we get with our dog, their solution no longer feels like a splurge.
​
It feels like a no-brainer.
​

​
Regret Aversion

Here's a truth every dog owner knows: We feel guilt when we think we're not doing enough for them.
​
The Farmer's Dog taps into this perfectly.
​
Their marketing doesn't just say "our food is better." It shows you what you're likely risking by feeding your dog processed kibble: shorter lifespans, digestive issues, dental disease, dull coats, and low energy.

The underlying message is clear: Every day you don't switch is a day your dog isn't as healthy as they could be.
​
We don't wanna feel like bad pet parents. So we buy the fresh food to avoid the regret of "what if I'd done more?"​
​

Social Proof

The Farmer's Dog doesn’t expect you to take their word for the difference fresh food can make.
​
So they display dogs who went from lethargic to energetic on their website. Dogs who lost stubborn weight. Dogs who finally finish their meals without treat bribery.

When we see others succeeding with a product—especially people we identify with (aka “good pet parents”)—we trust it more.
​
So we’re more likely to buy the food for our own dogs.

🤔 Thinking About Your Business

The Farmer’s Dog has delivered over one billion meals—and counting. Paws for applause, folks. But you don’t have to start selling dog food to use some of their smart techniques.

Ask yourself…
​

Q: What story can you use that shows instead of tells?​
Don't just list boring benefits of your product or service. Paint a vivid picture of the life your customer wants to live, and how your offer is the bridge that gets them there. When they can see themselves in that story, the decision to buy becomes obvious.
​
​Q: What regret are you helping customers avoid?
​Identify what keeps your customers up at night—the "what ifs" that haunt them—and show how your product protects them from that pain. When you help customers make decisions they'll feel good about long-term, you’re not “selling”—you’re solving.​
​
​Q: Which testimonials *really* matter?
​Your best marketers are your happiest customers. But not all testimonials are created equal. Focus on the specific transformations your target audience actually cares about experiencing. When potential buyers see people like them solving the exact problem they're facing, objections melt away.

​
💥 The Short of It

The Farmer's Dog didn't just reinvent dog food. They rewired how we think about feeding our dogs.
​
By using emotional storytelling, regret aversion, and smart social proof, they turned a bowl of (fresh) dog food into a billion-dollar biz backed by love—and approved by vets.
​
Turns out, the fastest way to a customer’s wallet… might just be through their dog’s stomach.
​​
​
​​Until next time, happy selling!

With ❤️ from Katelyn and Jordyn​

​